In the current debate about the future of our jail facility, a few realities must
be addressed with clarity and unity. Yes, the proposed changes come with a cost - but they are not optional. In order to comply with TCI (Tennessee Corrections Institute) standards, we must either upgrade or replace the current facility. If we do not, we risk losing state certification and funding, and would likely be required to pay other municipalities to house our inmates—an unsustainable long-term expense.
There are essentially two perspectives in this debate. One group favors
retrofitting the existing facility. This position is often based on the understandable concern over costs and a desire to avoid increasing taxes. Some also fear that relocating the jail might place it near neighborhoods or schools. However, that is not part of the current proposal.
The second perspective advocates for moving the jail off the square and
constructing a new, modern facility in a more appropriate location. This vision aligns with the ongoing revitalization of our downtown and opens up an opportunity to redevelop the valuable real estate currently occupied by the jail. By converting that central property into a commercial or mixed-use space, we could generate new revenue, attract visitors, and create jobs—all of which relieve pressure on the individual tax base.
This is not just a debate about buildings. It is about shaping the future of
Smithville.
The truth is, our town needs additional tax revenue. Our property taxes are
among the lowest in the region, which has attracted new residents—but not all growth is created equal. Without a strategy to increase local economic participation, this population influx strains our roads, schools, and other infrastructure without proportionate financial support. That’s a recipe for decline, not sustainability.
Let’s also not forget that many of the individuals moving here, and even
long-time residents, spend their money elsewhere—especially when our local ordinances or limited commercial offerings drive them to surrounding towns for shopping, dining, or entertainment. When that happens, those dollars are gone. They do not fund our schools, repave our roads, or pay our police. That’s revenue we can’t afford to lose.
This is not a call to turn Smithville into something it’s not. No one wants to
lose the charm, safety, and sense of community that make our town special. But we cannot preserve what we love by standing still. Responsible growth means planning for the future—not just reacting to the present.
Some worry that embracing change means embracing higher taxes. But we
can—and must—grow smarter. The key lies in increasing revenue through commercial vitality and tourism. Just look at how the state of Tennessee manages without an income tax: by generating revenue through consumption, much of it paid by visitors. We can do the same on a local level—if we invest in the right areas.
Nashville, just down the road, is one of the fastest growing cities in America. Whether we like it or not, that momentum is moving outward. We can resist it—or we can shape it. By making deliberate choices now, we can ensure that Smithville grows in a way that reflects our values: safe neighborhoods, strong schools, a vibrant downtown, and a thriving economy that benefits all.
This moment is not about abandoning tradition; it’s about stewarding our
future. Let’s not allow inertia or fear to decide for us. Let’s come together to make thoughtful, courageous decisions that allow Smithville to flourish—not just for us, but for the next generation.
Erin Fennell
105 West Main Street
Smithville, TN 37166
